# Manual claim audit key

All organisations, claims and source cards are fictional. This key was written manually and is not a captured research-product output.

| Claim | Status | Reason | Narrow correction or action |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| R1 current £18 price | Unverified | S1 is withdrawn and cannot prove current price | Obtain current quote, currency, tax, term and minimum seats |
| R1 no minimum | Unverified for current terms; inaccurately attributes no-minimum to S1 | S1 described a historical five-seat minimum; it cannot establish the current minimum | Remove the no-minimum assertion; obtain current terms |
| R2 Pro CSV audit export | Contradicted | S2 says Enterprise only | Evaluate required Enterprise plan before purchase |
| R3 independent certification | Unverified | Preparation for assessment is not a completed certificate | Ask for current certificate, scope, issuer and dates; do not conclude insecurity |
| R4 independent study | Contradicted | S4 is supplier-run | Label the source's relationship accurately |
| R4 every team saves 28% total work | Partially supported only after narrowing; broad claim unsupported | S4 reports one drafting task with volunteers and omits review/correction and control assignment | Describe only the supplier's limited observation, or exclude it from decision evidence |

Original recommendation is not adequately supported. A current quote, correct plan and security evidence remain necessary before making a purchasing decision. No purchase is authorised by this practice exercise.

Expected corrected brief: Current pricing is unverified. The fictional feature page assigns CSV audit export to Enterprise. The supplied security evidence does not establish certification. The supplier's drafting-time claim cannot predict total team savings. Obtain missing evidence before deciding.